Capparis brevispina


In C. rheedii, according to Flora of British India and Gamble, Flowers are 4.5 inches diameter whereas, in C. brevispina, flowers are 1.5-2 inches in diameter. Further, 2 lower petals are yellowish, changing to red-brown in C.brevisina but in C.rheedii, 2 lower petals close together with a yellow spot;  
 
Flora of Eastern Ghats: Hill Ranges of South East India, Volume 1 By T. Pullaiah, D. Muralidhara Rao, K. Sri Ramamurthy (2002- Description & Keys- Capparis grandis, Capparis nilgiriensis, Capparis decidua, Capparis sepiaria, Capparis olacifolia, Capparis divaricata, Capparis brevispina, Capparis zeylanica, Capparis floribunda (syn. of Capparis tomentosa Lam.) & Capparis roxburghii



 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/af9eb350b33d32c8/Capparis%20sp.%20fruit2.jpg?part=0.4&view=1&vt=ANaJVrFyz6IUluy3Z7KP_HFozR_6s84ww1j1VOZRzAcn-0rWiEIel6iR5CcygvsCP0iCrI0gf7d-5y4IqdmWg-LoXYF1jjTG1ZXP--y4oBYcDXT0DOiNlXQ
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/af9eb350b33d32c8/Capparis%20sp.%20fruit%201.jpg?part=0.3&view=1&vt=ANaJVrGtJoAEqX2F0W8VEmCX2zi5kMd4YQRWfzrTVSmF4LFnen442qk4LVVhLwTXwzVowAVz2eEuHkHSyt-OMrXOM-62FylJF21tHFzCVzBysUYUY9yQFnU
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/af9eb350b33d32c8/Capparis%20sp.2.jpg?part=0.2&view=1&vt=ANaJVrFa09BxIQUxhSV-2soB3my-4vW624O2AMfu2r_r3G1o0GRe-Ylm5HvK4jOeZTE7Nmzuf67NAohV7yXHyKWILkwgIKypwYuW-EWMAjzetbCybyl_AA8
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/af9eb350b33d32c8/Capparis%20sp%201.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrGlE0-QHK3ldmn6H3jrFD_NLjE5DnIxeJ_k8iMbNgpI6yzb1ackculI6RB4hjL4hnuro094cqvu_I4GjF3RKuZJrCmO36zvHThHYXY3QSV-OHy_1BA
AR13,2010 Capparis sp. :  Attachments (4).  9 posts by 6 authors.
Date/Time- latter half of the year
Location-Place, Altitude, GPS- Nanmangalam reserve forest-dry,evergreen ,thorn - near Chennai city
Habitat-Garden/ Urban/ Wild/ Type- wild
Plant Habit- Tree/ Shrub/ Climber/ Herb- shrub
Height/Length-4-5 ft
Leaves Type/ Shape/ Size-
Inflorescence Type/ Size- about 7cm width total
Flowers Size/ Colour/ Calyx/ Bracts-
Fruits Type/ Shape/ Size Seeds- fruits 4-6 cm and more when split open.
Other Information like Fragrance, Pollinator, Uses etc.-
From Flowers of India.net the flower seems to fit the description for Capparis rheedi but it is mentioned there that C. rheedi is endemic to Western Ghats. The fruit is as shown and birds were found to feed on it ( tastes sweet like custard apple and packing is similar). Experts' comments sought. Thanks

.... most probably Capparis rheedii
Capparis rheedi
or commonly Rheed's Capper
C. rheedei is a plant of evergreen forest. Flowers axillary, thorns straight, upper petals with a yellow/purple blotch is C. brevispina DC. I am seeing pictures for the first time.
I just glanced through the message posted by ... on Capparis sps. It has been identified by many members of the group as C.rheedii and supposed to be endemic to western ghats. If this plant is endemic to the w.ghats it should have been included in the Gamble Flora of Madras Presidency, which includes plants from Western ghats as well, either in the same name or as a synonym. But I donot find any such plant name in the Gamble flora. Furthermore, the experts who have identified it as C.rheedii have not given the synonyms, not found even in the flowers of India. The limited descriptions provided by ..., when checked, roughly tallies with Capparis brevispina described in Gamble flora. But this is not a confirmation as the full description of the plant is not available.
Looking forward for further comments by the experts as to (a) why C.rheedii is not mentioned in the Gamble flora or (b) Whether C. brevispina has been identified as C.rheedii or (c) C.rheedii is a new inlcusion to Capparis group
I am forwarding the last mail I received from ... on the Capparis sp. From the details given it seems to fit Capparis brevispina with the obvious feature being large fruit size

I am providing the data available in Gamble flora , vol. 1 pp31 and 32.
key
Mature branches leafless: -
thorns straight; flowers under 1 in. across, red, fruit globose red........................ aphylla
Mature branches leafy:-
Flowers solitary or nearly so:-

Ovary glabrous, grooved, flowers 2.5 - 3 in, across:-
Thorns hooked , leaves pubescent beneath; flowers white; fruit slightly granular, ablong .............. grandiflora.
Thorns straight; leaves glabrous; flowers red; fruit rugose, globular...................................... stylosa.
Ovary tomentose, flowers white tinged with yellow:-
Flowers 1.5 to- 2 in. across:-
Pedicel not less than 1/2 the gynophore :-
Berry ovoid; leaves 1.5 - 2.5in. long....... brevispina
Berry fusiform, narrowed into the gynophore; leaves 3-5 in. long....................................fusifera
Pedicels 5 times shorter than the gynophore;  Berry .7 in. across, black ......................alacifolia
Flowers 4-5 in across; thorns minute or 0................heyneana

Flowers in racemes, umbels , corymbs or panicles:-
key provided for 11 species. I am not typing the details as they are not relevant for the present species.
C.brevispina :- Dry forest tracts of N.Circars, Nellore, Salem and Tinnevelly , usual near the coast.
A handsome shrub with conspicuous flowers
I hope the details are sufficient.

   
Capparis rheedii: I just glanced through the message posted by ...on Capparis sps. It has been identified by many members of the group as C.rheedii and supposed to be endemic to western ghats. If this plant is endemic to the w.ghats it should have been included in the Gamble Flora of Madras Presidency, which includes plants from Western ghats as well, either in the same name or as a synonym. But I donot find any such plant name in the Gamble flora. Furthermore, the experts who have identified it as C.rheedii have not given the synonyms, not found even in the flowers of India. The limited descriptions provided by..., when checked, roughly tallies with Capparis brevispina described in Gamble flora.  But this is not a  confirmation as the full description of the plant is not available.
Looking forward for further comments by the experts as to (a) why C.rheedii is not mentioned in the Gamble flora or (b) Whether C. brevispina has been identified as C.rheedii or  (c) C.rheedii is a new inlcusion to Capparis group 
Capparis rheedii is mentioned in Gamble flora as C.heyneana, according to T S Nayar (2006) and N Sasidharan (2004). It has one more synonym C. baducca. They have mentioned C. brevispina as a separate species with a synonym C.zeylanica.
 
 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/d0628c54bae605e4/Capparis.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrFGQUMPaa4WIY7uurdThgH9Ovx_PhjCNLnFlVwZntioedYEGjvynu6hwtG4QIOsV4IkHJjr68soAnpHwoFt1YbTTar7uJxpa6rh9sCJp_AvMy59i6U
Capparis in Jijamata Udyan: Capparis once again in the focus. Large shrub or small tree 2 m tall. Leaves 3-6 cm, elliptic, acute, cuneate; petioles 3 mm. Flowers axillary, 3-5 cm. Fruits not seen.
Flowering in Jijamata Udyan, Mumbai on 10 Feb. 2011. ID leads to C. brevispina DC. as per Flora of Maharashtra BSI. Pls validate.  

- So far I was thinking the plant (same as the picture posted by ..., and ... pics in flickr), which i saw in TDEF along east coast as C. rheedii. When Giby said 'it is endemic to W.Ghats', i realized there is something wrong with my id. My plant can not be C.rheedii then. Now I verified with the Floras by Gamble and Matthew. The descriptions (as well as distribution) match well with C. brevispina, as also identified by ...
- Plant around Mumbai is C. zeylanica L. (syn C. horrida L. f.) whereas plant syn. of C. brevispina DC. is C. zeylanica sensu Hook. f. & Thoms. Yes, it can be confusing unless you refer to the floras. Plant in this thread differs from C. rheedei DC. in respect of leaves smaller, flowers smaller, petals narrower and not pale blue and the coloured patch on petals turning purple before fading. No fruits seen to differenciate.

- Thank you .. for the discussion and pointing out the fact why it can be brevispina not rheedii. Now I too think that it is C.brevispina.
In C. rheedii, according to Flora of British India and Gamble, Flowers are 4.5 inches diameter whereas, in brevispina, flowers are 1.5-2 inches in diameter. Further, 2 lower petals are yellowish, changing to red-brown in C.brevisina but in C.rheedii, 2 lower petals close together with a yellow spot.
- The intention of posting a plant seen in a garden is to ascertain the ID and to trace its origin. I have not come accross this plant in Maharashtra though it is reported in the BSI flora of Maharashtra. I would be keen to know if anyone on the group (besides .. in Eastern ghats) has seen the plant in wild habitat.

- .. Every one is saying Capparis rheedii except ... who is using Capparis rheedei. Logically .. sir is right as, according to latin, any person's name if transformed into species epithet, if it ends with a vowel, then it cant have double "i" and hence it should be "rheedei" and not "rheedii".
On IPNI it is given as Capparis rheedei!
But when I looked into the protologue, it says, Capparis rheedii, which is logically incorrect, but taxonomically it has to be accepted.

 
 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/30d971bf78d6e692/IMG_9868.jpg?part=0.3&view=1&vt=ANaJVrGP-ZQRlSGbl1vKVWFIYKEEkvVT_Jk7PwVlLjmFVWTId6lBVTWaXpuO6-TyW5hEUdar_wZ9bZUMop_inTTcuh7ZFz0FTFRp13HMcY2Wpu3vZtLdI3s
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/30d971bf78d6e692/IMG_9864.jpg?part=0.2&view=1&vt=ANaJVrEc6wS30OyurOzX166pL2c9bNDRC_sTYsFKtsvv8CkkVxqD-a2VoU0HJj_RavYZqzBwPLxE80yWhetaJq0GQNXPw_aZJJ2pdwpum06OOSGnEbo3tQg
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/30d971bf78d6e692/IMG_9863.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrEx16wYx53ORcwoXO1gA1m8b-YP6oyQuarFTWyQnE-J4ay7oU0clAZS0AnvIY2KeEgSj-seQMNNFwdXDgxcWpC3MDHw38MGdxb8HJesD2_eXdHs1Xg
Capparis brevispina:  Sharing few pics of Capparis brevispina from Veer Jijamata udyan, Mumbai.
Family:
Capparaceae
Date/Time: 14-04-2012 / 10:20AM
Plant Habit: Shrub
Habitat: Cultivated, Garden.


 
https://c6.staticflickr.com/3/2167/2369724861_bcf630fc2c_b.jpg
https://c8.staticflickr.com/4/3202/2369722495_9d208fb250_b.jpg
Capparaceae and Cleomaceae fortnight :: Capparis brevispina DC. at VJBU :: DV04 : 2 images. 4 posts by 3 authors.
Capparis brevispina DC. 
at Veermata Jeejabai Bhosale Udyan on 23 MAR 08  
 
 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/16869c18539bfb02/IMG_9871.jpg?part=0.4&view=1&vt=ANaJVrH36iZIH21CZMig_BmjXrSsAo20ilNnVd3n3uX8tLL_hixkOB3xi3MRN4AE6mZdxqcWgo3NLWuLlfuQrCs-5Dv-xKKIxvuplIDepq8nmKdZJXpHBvc
Capparis brevispina from Veer Jijamata udyan, Mumbai.
Family: Capparaceae
Date/Time: 14-04-2012 / 10:20AM
Plant Habit: Shrub
Habitat: Cultivated, Garden.


 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/21087c969d4181e3/Rheed%20Caper%203.jpg?part=0.3&view=1&vt=ANaJVrHpzHCSGE2kRWqPGZf08o6DgejxXbhVUGc9Ekc4zmmsRVzMD1LF6qZK9aHABq2YoEfJNJ0O-TzIZ1TDuzbvm5urfm2RH8MI_VF9g4hYQpszOXNsSvU
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/21087c969d4181e3/Rheed%20Caper%206.jpg?part=0.4&view=1&vt=ANaJVrF35-HjU0OwG_uZPKL_g-44qHWeGrE2HfNL20HrgROwWp4Oc7jeANVLRDGQI268sqvOqIp6ExIxgYoiQV89b920CpY2Yy9y4ak0oWH1tITIo8MtTnM
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/21087c969d4181e3/Rheed%20Caper%202.jpg?part=0.2&view=1&vt=ANaJVrERMy2-VBuwj601er8t9sCqybeuojcxSU80gz0hdF1KI2XxBiE5P27pbj818nu6yJjsR8YtGL6InZ7j_3KJKQWFLeDSm8jSZ6unpGY0zwwiV2qjueo
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/21087c969d4181e3/Rheed%20CAper%201.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrE0VCplEOGOXko0Zrpsux6hZW3lsZxPRdVEDgpPJrecBwWZ8gx_iHvvd2XjeAXvbq3arKovazvXM8R5Ouu1DM7zcAUuyEFVI-L6bPEvitRDfSrnags
Capparaceae and Cleomaceae Fortnight : Caper Sp. (NSJ-05 06/09/2013) :  Attachments (4). 5 posts by 4 authors.
Caper Sp (Looks like Rheed caper) from Jijamata Udyan, Mumbai
Capparis brevispina may be
Capparis brevispina.


 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/deb7d3d230e0ec3f/Image00172.jpg?part=0.2&view=1&vt=ANaJVrFkCCyl8pfDW8AgXQNHyMxr7st4VTSBylfR5znOrPIslhO1XzPe5NjYzAqEr4Z4uuletPVl8CWrl0_Wm5oC1l7YkXG0Xnc4rDcwrEa_oYYj7W3do6Q
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/deb7d3d230e0ec3f/Image00171.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrH5vjAvccPc63SXxbi9TzKY7acWEN7Yf0DaA2_8oyGBuAvSm6qMpg1Ka2wiPWRcnPT2xrnlpad0FnVVUpWAQ5wwnleT-E3vPv2mFRTmELk2GiuQsmk
Flower for ID : 21012014-DC-1 : Attachments (2). 6 posts by 4 authors.  
Found this flowering plant on a hillock (at an altitude of about 25 metres from MSL) at Mangalajodi, Odisha. Submitted for id please,
Shot on 16.01.2014
It may be Capparis brevispina
Agree with ... Capparis brevispina DC.
 
 
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-6DoE_FMhI7g/V-IBl1j_hqI/AAAAAAAAA8k/wpLq2BH0sPkxy94_criGXph3K7jzpHwfgCLcB/s1600/DSC_0336%2B-%2BCopy.JPG
Capparis brevispina DC : Attachments (1). 1 post by 1 author.
Capparis brevispina DC, Fam: Capparaceae
Shrub near chennai scrub jungle.
Flowers showy
 
 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/1fcf806ebe3539d8/Capparis%20sp.JPG?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrF4Iy_MPWtKzburWbqnt_vFCwRu-twgyHALHcHy7UlSOahXOz-Hq8T3qX0NZozpk7KLD8skIC9-vavVi1Ilv0NU-nHKa01H3yJq7jlz-Qad9yzuXog
Capparis brevispina DC :  2 posts by 2 authors. Attachments (1).
Capparis brevispina DC, Fam: Capparaceae
Shrub near chennai scrub jungle.
Flowers showy
Very beautiful picture
Capparis brevispina DC, fruiting twig from Thirukalukundram hill, Kancheepuram dt, Tamilnadu. 1 image.
  
 
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-f9ULQ_imyYk/V-IDVbx_3PI/AAAAAAAAA88/pu7gng721TALHkGe-C3gudKFqdwhId1BACLcB/s1600/DSC_0337%2B-%2BCopy.JPG
Capparis brevispina DC, : 1 post by 1 author. 2 images.
Fruiting twig from Thirukalukundram area of Kancheepuram dt, Tamil nadu observed 10 days back. (Sept.'16)
 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/27c67edc8aa35/20170306_175113.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrFEgHp8DJ3C_2D2QmyiJpxH1KXPcwEs0si1XJ3gX8EsQm-MeED8rrSlBBhnGFVvxdixgy6Ny0kuo0vljRm6FnrHD_RWmoW9l1RK3lfm7KfbToMLVYc

200717BHAR1 : 5 posts by 2 authors. Attachments (1)
Found in Vandalur -Perungalathur Hills. (Its a reserved forest.)
Taken in Chennai, Tamil Nadu.

Pl. Check comparative images at capperis is page in efi site. Pl. Also check the spelling of botanical name.  

Pl. check comparative images at genera page in efloraofindia (efi) site at Capparis 
Capparis brevispina- Confirmed

 
 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/2375938c8c269/20170801_174842.jpg?part=0.2&view=1&vt=ANaJVrHZUW2AIYYUCB9fTmZm-7OLjfcreyPpTSY7UPyDtBfSAZ2LI7X93FVk2Cbemxc0oBU68aw4b9gaxl3tMDPZLP5fHotZQmgBH0RSu770RNDPyJniytk
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/2375938c8c269/20170801_174833.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrFIxC_1rS41-oBX8vRXwB-HMCodZD0VO8BAtlpXRT1uXgSbTzbYbYyvxwuBk0tkBORrIFcHoHf0e23fDwTlNxZj2zQszUAYLHqwpmT-XX5hS1v9-XU
01082017BHAR2 : 7 posts by 3 authors. Attachments (2)
Found in Vandalur forest. Chennai.
Shrub.
A lot of insects are feeding on the fruit.
Fungi formed of over ripened fruit.
Lot of seeds inside the fruit.
The structure of fruit is not attractive for me.
Any gall? 
Check for Capparaceae
The fruit matches with capparis brevisipina.

 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/322ed56c1ab96/IMG_20180307_132216.jpg?part=0.2&view=1&vt=ANaJVrHO_ItSRG1fWCk-cJHlgMRfWs-67wJ4PYwd-gdllBHLvwUm2MkHT7mQljGVDeOJSdAUdt21TrMjkpUMqpHJHuhmr18MSmtZleZbdvPLBLzRr-DW6Wk
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/322ed56c1ab96/IMG_20180307_132228.jpg?part=0.3&view=1&vt=ANaJVrFeLB4Hbdnn5aUaxr7KFz16c9G5u1Z5GA84iACR8Nu9lhuG4gl9VsQBcl_s7MEpMFKZJKEb92lSBgoefmdoGBWx6QFBF-ZXY397AHrURLnx2vXgP98
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/322ed56c1ab96/IMG_20180307_132201.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrEUv2qpQFx4JJd9o-uMf5B_tBGwxCi-FFu0_dF6vuUppJtH7F3GeLbI0F-bCGYP-WORYlv_LZWlgcWZeFQc2EjkLEaeEOCB8Fc2Lmg3Geq41E31fhc

Fwd: Capparis brevispina DC.? : 2 posts by 1 author. Attachments (3)
Can you please identify this species from these three images?

Appears close as per images at 

 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/9e8658e51afc9/20180802174920_IMG_9210.JPG?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrFTZwGSMHvTRf7jRTO3kQhjt3dqZMWoSeRHQdnEcqoSjQBF7vT4BKn33HWt6yU9rWK-yC22l-3OVVkkzJYs_JaEt47SL5c5aR2YaJ4iAlz7nl-ihkE
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/9e8658e51afc9/20180802174917_IMG_9209.JPG?part=0.2&view=1&vt=ANaJVrFOxrUB1Ucv9CQYQVZBagC4zWtDZYF-2W_hQ9-hPeQJRXiwV3isNpcFXOBT776F35mZ4zRjtXWfqJ8Hw0hkXxo4rjLHFN54ty8pRKyXBVGW7l7Gs1U

Capparis brevispina : 2 posts by 2 authors. Attachments (2)
Found in Puthupattu near Pondicherry.





References:
Comments