Erigeron annuus ?

Erigeron annuus ?;   
 
This Asteracean was shot from Chakrata region, tentatively identified as Erigeron pulchellus... please provide id..
E. annuus could be considered.


 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/31e4be5f7e92c/Symhiotrichum%20pilosum-Dubia%2016Yamunanagar-IMG_8423-Yamunanagar-1.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrEoW2rteqBzlEcIHg_IicqpiTQZNC6_lRuOln26NUvz4GIqPjrVzrPwRLIOPV6CHX-eV8FlkpOb5LJ0cfvu67EwpLG7gk8dZSjwIVb0ggbRZpagS1c
This erect branched herb was clicked from along roadsides in Yamunanagar, Haryana on May 24, 2015.  I hope it narrows down to Symphiotrichum pilosum, it has been reported from J & K as per Flora of India 12:99, 1995, but listed as excluded species, because being perhaps escape from cultivation. Related species S. ericioides has spine tipped phyllaries.  

I am having doubts as per close up images at Minnesota Wildflowers as phyllaries appears to be different.
May I request you to pl. post original of 1st image.

Here it is ... 
Attachments (1)- 3 mb. 

Yes, it looks different and is not Symphiotrichum pilosum

I had posted this common picture on Indian Flora facebook, with this plant on right, I am also sharing plant on the left still unidentified. I agree ray florets are much narrower in my right plant shared above, could be some Erigeron.
I am sharing another plant separately also.
Attachments (3) 

Reply in from another thread:
Rather my other upload which I suspect Symphiotrichum pilosum is more closer to E. annuus 

 
 
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/17e5ecb5b167a/Dubia%2015-%20Yamunanagar-IMG_8412-Yamunanagar-2.jpg?part=0.1&view=1&vt=ANaJVrHn70fvMlskI4TQugbFboOkYexh2e__hDAKFDesHgxhrKF7X2ZGYk8aAt9poSCP_t-luk9ZCYo3T9S8AxyUqdSaeq7ur5MbV59WJuItPW6Ua96lRDs
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/17e5ecb5b167a/Dubia%2015-Yamunanagar-IMG_8410-Yamunanagar-1.jpg?part=0.2&view=1&vt=ANaJVrEn256JfUDesOhtDZJvMs7q2fEDLtIyV4kmY3yyA_pEQyt-PRdviHJbNzkkZLX0Ugd8sPUDr68yMlsBn_-1KE9mPEltEGvJV7mCC3msFhtnupY58WU
https://08511630493324166816.googlegroups.com/attach/17e5ecb5b167a/Dubia%2015-Yamunanagar-IMG_8408-a.jpg?part=0.3&view=1&vt=ANaJVrEGxIRubMX6bGGbpClbuCSWvY7JhkqFLsaMjS1CYLj9CIYFVD2GGXnLUSh3BudBJe5gzKuhbdFVA-ZdJ6gbFoko_WviGdcwGWj3HCxoucg0Ju57ZgE
Herb for ID from along Road from Yamuna Nagar to Renuka ji, May 24, 2015. 


Ray florets are too short for E. annuus  

Here are two plants of E. annuus, one from Kashmir and one from Chakrata.
Rather my other upload which I suspect Symphiotrichum pilosum is more closer to E. annuus 

Anyway, appears to be Erigeron species only as per comparative images at Astereae




Comments